An interesting facebook thread has prompted me to ask;
(No AF option!!)
In touch
Moderator: moderators
- sarah_lennon
- Jamie Heaslip
- Posts: 15372
- Joined: April 19th, 2006, 4:14 pm
In touch
Ici, ici, c'est Dublin 4
Re: In touch
I've seen similar instances before. It was very close but really a simple call. A lot of people in the bar were unsure but I was convinced from pretty much the first replay. Live, I thought it was a try though.
I could understand the Sky Sports confusion because they were similarly flustered by Catt in the World Cup Final. His foot lands in the field of play but slides so his toe hits the edge of the chalk.
I could understand the Sky Sports confusion because they were similarly flustered by Catt in the World Cup Final. His foot lands in the field of play but slides so his toe hits the edge of the chalk.
Re: In touch
Try for me!
In fact I'd be willing to give them this try in exchange for Fourie's try in the second test to be ruled out.
Fair?
In fact I'd be willing to give them this try in exchange for Fourie's try in the second test to be ruled out.
Fair?
- sarah_lennon
- Jamie Heaslip
- Posts: 15372
- Joined: April 19th, 2006, 4:14 pm
Re: In touch
It was Cueto rather than Catt in the World Cup Final was it not? I agree that both decisions were correct.ronk wrote:I've seen similar instances before. It was very close but really a simple call. A lot of people in the bar were unsure but I was convinced from pretty much the first replay. Live, I thought it was a try though.
I could understand the Sky Sports confusion because they were similarly flustered by Catt in the World Cup Final. His foot lands in the field of play but slides so his toe hits the edge of the chalk.
Re: In touch
I didn't think it was in touch.
Re: In touch
It was. It was the sight of Catt's reaction that played a trick on my memory.dipper wrote:It was Cueto rather than Catt in the World Cup Final was it not? I agree that both decisions were correct.ronk wrote:I've seen similar instances before. It was very close but really a simple call. A lot of people in the bar were unsure but I was convinced from pretty much the first replay. Live, I thought it was a try though.
I could understand the Sky Sports confusion because they were similarly flustered by Catt in the World Cup Final. His foot lands in the field of play but slides so his toe hits the edge of the chalk.